Paper Mario: Color Splash Is Better Than Its Reputation — Here’s Why
Paper Mario: Color Splash has a weak story and divisive combat, but stands out through its humor, visuals and music. The game disappointed longtime fans and sold fewer than one million copies.
Paper Mario: Color Splash was not the game longtime fans wanted, but its reputation as a complete failure is overstated. It is better understood as a solid Mario adventure than as a strong Paper Mario role-playing game.
The Wii U title stands out for its writing, colorful levels and playful music. Its story is shallow, however, and its card-based combat has several significant weaknesses.
Sales and a troubled series direction
Color Splash never came to Nintendo Switch. The reasons included backlash from dedicated fans, Intelligent Systems moving on to Paper Mario: The Origami King, and sales below one million copies—an unusual result for a Mario game.
After Paper Mario: Sticker Star removed partners, deeper storylines and many distinctive characters, Color Splash continued much of that approach. Most of its non-player characters are still Toads, although Mario does have an unusual companion in Huey, a paint bucket.
Humor built around recurring jokes
The game’s strongest feature is its writing. Nearly every character has a joke, and Color Splash follows through on its own comic details. A running gag about an “expert on bridge experts,” for example, returns many hours after it is first introduced.
In another scene, a Shy Guy tells Mario on a train that their next meeting will be on the battlefield. Much later, a defeated Shy Guy is revealed to be the same character. This commitment to recurring jokes gives the adventure charm even when its central story falls short.
Diorama visuals and playful music
The levels are designed like miniature dioramas. Mario visits plains, beaches, an ocean, distant islands, a train and a volcano, with each area given a colorful, decorative look.
The soundtrack matches the game’s light tone, including its comedic battle themes. The Koopalings receive distinct music, from Wendy’s pirate-style chants to Ludwig’s upbeat theme. The final boss track is also effective, even if it does not match earlier entries.
Card-based combat limitations
Outside combat, Mario can uncover secrets with jumps and hammers, alter scenery through Huey’s cutouts and restore unpainted areas with his paint hammer. Battles rely on cards, some of which begin unpainted, making both the card supply and paint capacity relevant.
Played cards disappear even when they were not needed for victory. If a Jump card ends a battle, cards for a hammer or Thing used in the same turn are lost as well. Battles expand the paint supply, but they remain one of the game’s weakest elements.
Later releases changed the context around Color Splash. Paper Mario: The Origami King moved the series somewhat closer to fan expectations, while the remake of Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door restored many requested features. That makes Color Splash easier to view as a flawed but often inventive adventure.
What we know
- Paper Mario: Color Splash works better as a Mario adventure than as the Paper Mario sequel fans wanted.
- The Wii U game sold fewer than one million copies and never received a Nintendo Switch version.
- Its strongest features are comedic dialogue, colorful diorama-like levels and playful music.
- The card-based combat removes unused cards after they are played.
Trust: Single source
- The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
- Sources: Nintendo Everything.
COMMUNITY
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
Loading comments…