Back to feed
Australian politicsSingle source

Victoria’s sole election debate brings rare drama as opposition leader leads audience poll

Victoria’s only election debate produced a rare burst of drama before early voting opened. Opposition leader Jess Wilson was judged the winner by 39% of the audience, while Greens leader Ellen Sandell received 25% and Premier Ben Carroll 7%.

Preferred on Google
Text size

Image: theguardian.com · Author: https://www.theguardian.com/profile/benita-kolovos · source articleEditorial excerpt for news reporting

Victoria’s sole election debate ended with opposition leader Jess Wilson leading an audience poll of 100 undecided voters. The Tuesday event took place at Melbourne’s Sofitel, one day before early voting opened.

39% of attendees picked Wilson as the debate winner. Greens leader Ellen Sandell received 25%, One Nation leader Warren Pickering 16% and Premier Ben Carroll 7%; 13% remained undecided.

Leaders trade sharp attacks

Wilson challenged Carroll over his refusal to name his predecessors, Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan. Carroll compared this with being able to name former premier Jeff Kennett, but did not name Andrews or Allan himself.

Wilson also said Carroll could not lecture her on policy costs, accusing Labor of building up $200bn in state debt. Carroll argued that the Liberal plans did not add up and would require cuts to healthcare funding.

Pickering compared Victoria with “Gotham City” over rising crime and promised to imprison more offenders, including by sending them to prisons interstate if necessary.

Sandell targets all three parties

Sandell joined the panel after a dispute over whether Pickering should be invited. She criticised Labor over gambling-industry donations, the Liberals over money from property developers and One Nation over its links to billionaire Gina Rinehart.

She also challenged Carroll over public-sector cuts and disputes with health workers, teachers, council workers and firefighters over pay. Wilson said the Greens and Coalition were too far apart for the Greens to support a minority Coalition government.

The two also clashed over pro-Palestinian protests in Melbourne’s CBD. Sandell defended peaceful protest, while Wilson said throwing rocks at police was not peaceful. Pickering also opposed politicians deciding who could receive protest permits.

Rail project and government record

Wilson left open the possibility of scrapping the multibillion-dollar Suburban Rail Loop after the Coalition reviewed signed contracts. She said that review was intended to determine whether the project should be abandoned.

Carroll acknowledged Labor’s mistakes during 12 years in government but pointed to 121 new schools, record NAPLAN results, the country’s highest-paid teachers and 17,000 additional nurses. He also defended his decision to establish a royal commission into alleged corruption on government construction sites.

There will be no further leaders’ debate after Carroll and Wilson failed to agree on terms for a free-to-air television event.

What we know

  • Jess Wilson led the post-debate audience poll with 39%.
  • Ellen Sandell received 25%, Warren Pickering 16% and Ben Carroll 7%.
  • The debate was held at Melbourne’s Sofitel before early voting opened.
  • Wilson left open scrapping the multibillion-dollar Suburban Rail Loop after a contract review.
  • No further debate will take place after Carroll and Wilson failed to agree on terms.

Trust: Single source

  • The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
  • Sources: The Guardian World.
Related news
View sources1

COMMUNITY

Discussion

—

Loading comments…