Back to feed
Digital platformsSingle source

U.S. government urges Supreme Court to reverse part of Apple contempt ruling

The U.S. Department of Justice urged the Supreme Court to reverse Apple’s contempt finding over a 27% commission on purchases made outside the App Store. It supports the ruling on Apple’s button restriction and seeks reconsideration of other issues by lower courts.

Preferred on Google
Text size

Image: 9to5mac.com · Author: Marcus Mendes · source articleEditorial excerpt for news reporting

The U.S. Department of Justice urged the Supreme Court to reverse Apple’s contempt finding for charging a commission on purchases directed outside the App Store. The department filed an amicus brief in the Apple-Epic Games case.

The Justice Department argued that civil contempt is appropriate only when the prohibited conduct is clearly covered by an injunction’s express terms. It said that standard was not met for the 27% commission.

DOJ supports ruling on buttons

The department nevertheless backed the lower courts’ finding concerning Apple’s “plain button” restriction. In its view, the injunction required Apple to allow both buttons and links, while Apple’s implementation effectively permitted links only.

For other issues, including restrictions on where external purchase links could appear, the department asked the Supreme Court to set aside the existing rulings and send those matters back to the lower courts for review under the “fair ground of doubt” standard.

Apple’s argument and case schedule

Apple argues that the original injunction did not expressly bar a commission on purchases made outside the App Store. The company also says upholding the contempt ruling would risk judicial overreach and leave businesses uncertain about what injunctions prohibit.

The Supreme Court agreed in late June to hear Apple’s challenge. Apple filed its opening merits brief last week, and Epic Games has until November 13 to respond.

The court also received briefs from the International Center for Law and Economics, the Computer & Communications Industry Association, NetChoice and the Software & Information Industry Association. Separately, district-court proceedings are examining how much, if any, commission Apple may charge on purchases made through external links.

What we know

  • The Justice Department asks the Supreme Court to reverse the contempt finding over Apple’s 27% commission.
  • It supports the ruling that Apple’s implementation improperly limited developers to links instead of allowing buttons too.
  • Epic Games must respond to Apple’s Supreme Court filing by November 13.
  • A district court is separately considering whether Apple may charge any commission on external-link purchases.

Trust: Single source

  • The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
  • Sources: 9to5Mac.
Related news
View sources1

COMMUNITY

Discussion

—

Loading comments…