Back to feed
Ukraine and NATOSingle source

US discusses two Ukraine NATO scenarios with Kyiv and Europe

The United States has discussed two scenarios involving Ukraine’s possible NATO membership with Ukrainian and European representatives. The Wall Street Journal reports that the talks took place over recent months and included territorial issues and security guarantees.

Preferred on Google
Text size

Image: bbc.com · Author: http://www.facebook.com/bbcnews · source articleEditorial excerpt for news reporting

The United States is discussing two possible end-of-war scenarios with Ukrainian and European representatives, both linked to Ukraine’s future NATO membership, the Wall Street Journal reports, citing participants in closed negotiations.

Under the first option, Ukraine would withdraw from the part of Donbas still under its control and receive full NATO membership in return. The second would freeze hostilities along the current front line, leave part of Donbas under Ukrainian control and provide security through an international agreement with the United States and possibly European countries.

Dublin and UAE talks

According to the newspaper, Donald Trump’s special envoy Steve Witkoff and his son-in-law Jared Kushner discussed the options with Volodymyr Zelensky and European representatives during meetings in Dublin. The idea was also raised in talks in the United Arab Emirates; one European leader told the WSJ that a similar scenario had been discussed as early as August.

The option linking NATO membership to territorial concessions had previously been considered unworkable. Early last year, Trump ruled out Ukraine joining the alliance, calling it unacceptable to Moscow, but participants said Witkoff and Kushner had repeatedly raised the idea with Europeans in recent months.

Russia is demanding that Kyiv abandon its NATO goal. Moscow also wants NATO’s military presence in Eastern Europe reduced to its 1997 level.

Western allies are divided over Ukraine’s membership. All NATO members must approve a new member: Emmanuel Macron supports discussing the possibility, while Germany opposes it.

Kyiv’s position on territory

After the Coalition of the Willing summit in Berlin on November 19, Zelensky said Ukraine would not simply hand its territory to Russia. He said any compromise must take Ukrainian public opinion into account and indicated he was ready to discuss territorial issues directly with Vladimir Putin.

The talks also covered security guarantees if Ukraine does not join NATO. Zelensky said political promises alone would not be enough; Kyiv wants American and European military personnel present in Ukraine and a pre-agreed response mechanism for any new Russian attack.

More than 25 leaders attended the Berlin summit. They urged Russia to accept a winter energy truce, stop attacks on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure and halt strikes on vessels carrying food through the Black Sea. Moscow rejected the possibility of an energy truce.

What we know

  • The US is discussing two scenarios linking Ukraine’s future NATO status to territorial arrangements or international security guarantees.
  • One option would require Ukraine to withdraw from the part of Donbas it still controls in exchange for full NATO membership.
  • The second would freeze fighting along the current front and provide guarantees from the US and possibly European countries.
  • Russia wants Ukraine to abandon its NATO bid and NATO’s military presence in Eastern Europe reduced to its 1997 level.

Trust: Single source

  • The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
  • Sources: BBC News Україна.
Related news
View sources1

COMMUNITY

Discussion

—

Loading comments…