Sakurai says Smash Bros. endured criticism for breaking from Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter
Super Smash Bros. director Masahiro Sakurai discussed the difficulty of making original games and recalled criticism aimed at the series’ first entry. He said its differences from Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter initially alienated some players, while also defining its gameplay.
Masahiro Sakurai told Denfaminicogamer that originality is not among the main factors determining a game’s sales, although he considers it important to game design.
Sakurai said that without a distinctive element, players would be better off playing the original work a game resembles. He cited Kirby as an example: its side-scrolling format needed a different play style from Super Mario Bros. to justify its existence.
Smash Bros. rejected standard fighting rules
Sakurai said the original Super Smash Bros. might not have continued if it had followed a conventional fighting-game structure: one-on-one matches, guarding, attacks and a knockout after a character’s energy was depleted. Instead, the team relied on damage accumulation and positioning.
The first Super Smash Bros. was criticized by players who struggled with its differences from Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter. Sakurai believed those new ideas made the game engaging rather than simply another conventional fighter.
Changes can create resistance
The director said players buy established series with expectations about their familiar style. Even a small change can feel wrong before players have a chance to recognize its strengths.
Sakurai described intentionally adding new ideas as difficult because there are no earlier examples to use when explaining the concept to staff or deciding how to develop it. He said similar challenges affected his games Meteos, Kid Icarus: Uprising, Kirby Air Ride and Air Riders.
Sakurai also discussed the risk that artificial intelligence could contribute to games that are unoriginal and difficult to play.
What we know
- Sakurai linked Smash Bros.’ identity to damage accumulation and positioning mechanics.
- The first game was criticized for differing from Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter.
- He considers originality important to design, despite ranking it low among sales factors.
- He cited Meteos, Kid Icarus: Uprising, Kirby Air Ride and Air Riders as games shaped by similar challenges.
Trust: Single source
- The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
- Sources: Nintendo Everything.
COMMUNITY
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
Loading comments…