Back to feed
Social mediaSingle source

Facebook promotes Crunchy Moms group where dangerous medical misinformation spreads

A Guardian investigation found widespread false claims about vaccines, measles and cancer treatments in Facebook’s Crunchy Moms group. The group has more than 490,000 members, while the platform took no action on more than 50 posts and comments reported by a journalist.

Preferred on Google
Text size

Image: theguardian.com · Author: https://www.theguardian.com/profile/michelle-r-smith · source articleEditorial excerpt for news reporting

Facebook’s Crunchy Moms group, which has more than 490,000 members, is a major channel for dangerous medical misinformation, while the platform promotes it in users’ feeds even when they have not searched for it. That is the finding of a Guardian investigation.

During a measles outbreak in Lancaster county, Pennsylvania, a parent asked the group for advice about vaccinating a three-year-old child. Members falsely claimed that measles could not be fatal, that vaccination spread the disease or that the vaccine was “poison”.

Pennsylvania has reported six measles-associated deaths this year, including two babies in Lancaster county. Health officials say the MMR vaccine is safe and the best protection against measles spreading and causing serious injury or death.

Facebook ignored more than 50 reports

A Guardian journalist reported more than 50 posts and comments to Facebook in May, July and September. They included claims that vaccines cause autism, measles is not deadly and the caustic substance black salve can treat cancer; the platform did not respond to any of the reports.

Meta said its policies allow people to discuss personal experiences and scientific research, and that it removes misinformation when it is likely to contribute directly to an imminent risk of physical harm. The company did not answer detailed questions about Crunchy Moms or the prevalence of such claims in the group.

Meta shifted its moderation approach

After the Covid-19 pandemic, Facebook placed greater emphasis on connecting users with accurate health information. Last year, however, Mark Zuckerberg said there was “too much censorship”; Meta then eliminated US fact-checkers and reduced active moderation of content other than the most severe or illegal material.

Meta says neither its policy nor its enforcement has changed since 2023. Scientists, doctors and public-health advocates told the Guardian that the current approach is again allowing false medical claims to circulate widely.

Renée DiResta, a Georgetown University professor who studies online manipulation, said the promotion of anti-science groups had harmed children in the past. Meta did not comment on one scientist’s description of Crunchy Moms as “the most dangerous group on Facebook”.

What we know

  • A Guardian investigation found dangerous medical misinformation circulating in the Crunchy Moms group.
  • The group has more than 490,000 members and appears in users’ feeds without them searching for it.
  • Facebook took no action on more than 50 reports involving claims about vaccines, measles and cancer treatments.
  • Pennsylvania has recorded six measles-associated deaths this year.

Trust: Single source

  • The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
  • Sources: The Guardian Technology.
Related news
View sources1

COMMUNITY

Discussion

—

Loading comments…