Back to feed
International courtsSingle source

Fears grow over US sanctions on ICJ judges before Myanmar genocide ruling

The International Court of Justice is due to rule on Thursday on whether Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, raising fears that Washington could sanction its judges. The US and Israel are concerned the judgment could establish a precedent for future genocide cases, including one involving Gaza.

Preferred on Google
Text size

Image: theguardian.com · Author: https://www.theguardian.com/profile/patrickwintour · source articleEditorial excerpt for news reporting

The International Court of Justice is due to rule on Thursday on whether Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya. Ahead of the judgment, fears have grown that the United States could sanction the judges if the ruling finds Myanmar responsible.

The court has never before held a state responsible for genocide. A central issue in such cases is proving an intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.

Arguments in the Myanmar case

Lawyers for Rohingya survivors say the Myanmar military’s conduct during operations in Rakhine state in 2016 and 2017, including killings as people fled, indicates an attempt to destroy the group. Myanmar denies genocide and says its operations targeted an insurgency.

A joint submission by the UK and five other mainly European states urged the court to assess all facts and circumstances comprehensively. It said genocide was not defined only by killings, with treatment of children, gender-based violence and forced displacement also relevant.

Washington’s warnings

The Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a thinktank close to the White House, has predicted that the US will sanction the ICJ if it issues a genocide ruling. Judges have sought advice on protecting their assets from possible US restrictions.

Mike Waltz, the US ambassador to the UN, accused ad hoc judge Navi Pillay of trying to lower the legal threshold for proving genocide. Gambia appointed Pillay to the case, and she is required to act as a jurist rather than as the country’s advocate; she was named a Nobel peace prize laureate in October.

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has also criticised international courts, saying global elites use international law to advance their interests. The US has already sanctioned International Criminal Court judges after it issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Link to the Gaza case

The US and Israel fear the Myanmar judgment could clarify how a government’s genocidal intent is established and make future proceedings against Israel over Gaza more likely. Israel has previously criticised adverse ICJ opinions and did not comply with its 2024 orders on increasing aid to Gaza and cooperating with Unrwa.

The ICJ settles disputes between states, while the International Criminal Court prosecutes individuals for war crimes and other international crimes. ICJ judges are elected by the UN Security Council and General Assembly for nine-year terms.

What we know

  • The ICJ will rule on Thursday whether Myanmar is responsible for genocide against the Rohingya.
  • The US could impose sanctions on the judges if the ruling is adverse to Myanmar.
  • Rohingya lawyers cite Myanmar military actions during the 2016–2017 operations.
  • Washington and Israel fear the judgment could set a precedent for Gaza proceedings.

Trust: Single source

  • The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
  • Sources: The Guardian World.
Related news
View sources1

COMMUNITY

Discussion

—

Loading comments…