Seven Bay Area cities pause data-centre construction ahead of US midterms
At least seven San Francisco Bay Area cities have temporarily halted data-centre construction ahead of the US midterm elections. San Francisco, Brisbane and Oakland set initial 45-day pauses.
At least seven cities in California’s San Francisco Bay Area have imposed temporary moratoriums on data-centre construction ahead of the US midterm elections. The pauses come in a region central to the artificial-intelligence industry and home to major technology companies.
Oakland approved its moratorium on October 6, after several days of protests outside City Hall. San Francisco, Brisbane and Oakland set initial construction pauses of 45 days, with the option to extend them.
Protesters have raised concerns about data centres’ electricity and water needs, and the possibility of higher power bills. Carlos Gutierrez, an activist with the environmental justice group Communities for a Better Environment, said some Oakland residents were considering disconnecting their power because of high prices while the city planned to supply electricity to a data centre.
Moratoriums enter the election campaign
The contest for the congressional seat Nancy Pelosi will leave at the end of the year, after 39 years in the House of Representatives, has put the issue in focus. Democratic candidates Connie Chan and Scott Wiener have taken opposing positions: Wiener rejects a blanket ban, saying it could undermine AI regulation, while Chan has pledged to seek a nationwide moratorium until responsible AI rules are in place. Chan played a leading role in securing San Francisco’s moratorium.
A University of Southern California poll in mid-October showed Wiener leading Chan 47% to 41%. An October CNBC poll found 63% of registered US voters opposed building data centres within 10 miles (16 kilometres) of their homes.
Cities face limits on review time
San Francisco-based political analyst Shum Preston suggested developers may have avoided challenging the pauses so as not to put local politicians in difficulty before the elections. He also said opposition could grow once the 45-day periods end.
In San Francisco, oversight is complicated by a city planning definition created in 2001, before the AI boom. Supervisor Shamann Walton, who sponsored the moratorium ordinance, said the outdated wording makes it difficult to count data centres and monitor their electricity and water use.
Roger Lin, a senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity, said 45 days was not enough for a full impact assessment. He said nondisclosure agreements can restrict local authorities’ access to information about data centres’ effects on air quality. Supporters of the AI industry, meanwhile, have presented data-centre growth as evidence of a flourishing sector with positive downstream effects for US communities.
What we know
- At least seven San Francisco Bay Area cities have imposed temporary data-centre construction moratoriums.
- Oakland approved its pause on October 6 after several days of protests.
- San Francisco, Brisbane and Oakland set initial moratorium periods of 45 days.
- A mid-October poll showed Scott Wiener leading Connie Chan 47% to 41%.
- A CNBC poll found 63% of registered US voters opposed data centres within 10 miles of their homes.
Trust: Single source
- The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
- Sources: Al Jazeera English.
COMMUNITY
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
Loading comments…