Apple and DOJ reach impasse over document cutoff in antitrust case
Apple and the U.S. Department of Justice told the court they are at an impasse over the cutoff for Apple’s document production in their antitrust case. The DOJ wants records updated through 30 days before fact discovery ends, now scheduled for late May 2027.
Apple and the U.S. Department of Justice jointly told the court they have failed to agree on the date through which the company must produce documents in the federal antitrust case.
The dispute centers on an agreed cutoff of June 20, 2025. The DOJ argues that repeated changes to the schedule require Apple to supplement its production much closer to the end of fact discovery.
Fact discovery now runs to May 2027
The parties initially expected fact discovery to finish on July 31, 2026. That deadline has been extended twice and is now scheduled for late May 2027.
The plaintiffs want Apple to include documents created up to 30 days before that phase ends. They say retaining the earlier cutoff could prevent the government from obtaining evidence of Apple’s alleged ongoing anticompetitive conduct.
Apple warns of a renewed review process
Apple says the June 20, 2025 date was part of a negotiated process and that the DOJ’s proposal would effectively restart document discovery, adding months of delay. The company says it made a substantial investment and used hundreds of contractors while largely completing its production over 12 months.
Apple says recollecting information from 54 custodians and other sources, then searching, reviewing and producing documents for an additional 22-month period, would take several more months. It is willing to consider targeted requests individually, but the DOJ says that approach would be unworkable and likely create further disputes.
Lawsuit filed in March 2024
The DOJ, 15 states and the District of Columbia sued Apple in March 2024. They accuse the company of illegally maintaining a monopoly in the smartphone market, restricting interoperability with rival products and making it harder for consumers to switch devices. Apple denies the allegations.
The parties have also disputed how many Apple employees’ records should be searched, whether documents from outside the United States must be produced, and Apple’s requests for records from 14 federal agencies. Apple rejects the suggestion that it alone caused the schedule extensions and says the government has yet to produce documents in response to most of its requests, which were served more than 15 months ago.
What we know
- Apple and the DOJ told the court they are deadlocked over the document-production cutoff.
- Fact discovery in the case is now scheduled to end in late May 2027.
- The DOJ wants Apple to produce records created through 30 days before discovery closes.
- Apple says reviewing material from 54 custodians and other sources would take several more months.
- The DOJ, 15 states and the District of Columbia filed the lawsuit in March 2024.
Trust: Single source
- The story relies on one publisher. A second independent confirmation has not been established from the cited sources.
- Sources: 9to5Mac.
COMMUNITY
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.
Loading comments…